Sentenza nº 5751 da Consiglio di Stato, 21 Novembre 2014
Data di Resoluzione: | 21 Novembre 2014 |
Emittente: | Consiglio di Stato |
Il Consiglio di Stato
in sede giurisdizionale (Sezione Quinta)
ha pronunciato la presente
DECISIONE
Vito Poli, Presidente FF
Francesco Caringella, Consigliere
Antonio Amicuzzi, Consigliere
Doris Durante, Consigliere
Nicola Gaviano, Consigliere, Estensore
per la riforma
della sentenza del T.A.R. CAMPANIA ? NAPOLI, SEZIONE V, n. 9316/2004, resa tra le parti, concernente perdita dei requisiti per l'assegnazione e conservazione di alloggio.
sul ricorso numero di registro generale 8800 del 2004, proposto da Prevete Aniello, rappresentato e difeso dall'avv. Guido Sorvino, con domicilio eletto presso Domenico Sabia in Roma, Via Fonteiana 65;
Comune di Sperone, rappresentato e difeso dagli avv. Domenico Vitale e Carmine Corrado, con domicilio eletto presso Luigi Napolitano in Roma, Via Sicilia 50;
Visti il ricorso in appello e i relativi allegati;
Viste le memorie difensive;
Visti tutti gli atti della causa;
Relatore nell'udienza pubblica del giorno 4 novembre 2014 il Cons. Nicola Gaviano e udito per la parte appellata l'avv. Di Bonito, per delega dell'avv. Vitale;
Ritenuto e considerato in fatto e diritto quanto segue.
FATTO e DIRITTO
Il sig. Aniello Prevete impugnava con ricorso al T.A.R. per la Campania l'ordinanza dell'Ufficio Tecnico Comunale di Sperone n. 1 del 19 gennaio 2004, che aveva dichiarato la perdita, da parte sua, dei requisiti previsti dall'art. 2 della L.R. n. 18/1997 per l'assegnazione e conservazione dell'alloggio comunale a suo tempo assegnatogli, conseguentemente pronunciando la sua decadenza dall'assegnazione dell'immobile e ordinandone il rilascio.
Il ricorrente, in sintesi, per un verso rivendicava di avere posseduto l'alloggio in modo pieno e ininterrotto, deducendo che i sopralluoghi effettuati dai VV.UU. -che avevano portato a conclusione opposta- non sarebbero stati adeguati; per altro verso, contestava che i componenti del proprio nucleo familiare fossero titolari di altra unità abitativa nel Comune, deducendo che il figlio Felice, pur proprietario di altro immobile, non avrebbe fatto più parte del nucleo stesso, in quanto trasferito a Treviso.
Resisteva all'impugnativa il Comune di Sperone, che ne deduceva l'infondatezza.
Il Tribunale adìto, con la sentenza n. 9316/2004 in epigrafe, emessa in forma semplificata, respingeva il ricorso, osservando che né le circostanze dedotte dal ricorrente, né la documentazione da questo esibita, erano idonee a revocare in dubbio le risultanze degli accertamenti condotti dall'Amministrazione.
Seguiva la proposizione contro tale sentenza del presente appello alla Sezione da parte del soccombente, che riproponeva le proprie primitive doglianze, estendendole alla sentenza che le aveva disattese, ma ne formulava anche di ulteriori.
Il Comune di Sperone si costituiva in resistenza al gravame anche in questo grado di giudizio.
Con memoria depositata il 24 settembre 2014, infine, l'Ente, dopo aver eccepito l'inammissibilità dei motivi nuovi contenuti nell'appello avversario, illustrava le ragioni dell'infondatezza delle relative censure.
Alla pubblica udienza del 4 novembre 2014 la...
Per continuare a leggere
RICHIEDI UNA PROVABuone notizie, abbiamo trovato un account attivo con questa email!
Puoi accedere qui.
Hai dimenticato la tua password?
Clicca qui per resettare la tua password.
A verification link has been sent to your email account!
Please click on the link that has been sent to your email account to verify your email and continue the registration process.
We have found that your academic organisation currently subscribes to vLex.
To receive access to vLex:
- Please contact your resource manager to setup an account.
- If you have an email address with the organisation, please use that.
We have found that your organisation currently subscribes to vlex.
To receive access to vLex:
- Use the following link to sign up from your portal.
- Please contact your resource manager to setup an account.
- If you have an email address with the organisation, please use that.
OR
You can signup for an individual account here.
Gli abbonati possono accedere alla versione segnalata di questo caso.
You can sign up for a trial and make the most of our service including these benefits.
Ci sono molte altre ragioni per abbonarsi.
-
Global Coverage
Access over 120 million legal information documents, including the largest collection of common law and civil law content on one intuitive and advanced service.
-
Updated with over 20,000 cases each month
Each month thousands of new cases and legal documents are added to vLex Justis, providing you with up-to-date content and a wider range of information to support your research.
-
AI-powered research
Are you confident your research is complete? Use our AI-powered tool, Vincent, to conduct truly comprehensive research, based on in-document search and analysis.
-
Know where to start your research
The only service to feature exclusive, comprehensive and up-to-date legal information from 130 jurisdictions. This includes the largest collections of common and civil law judgments, exclusive law reports, legislation, regulations, dockets, books, journals and international news.
Buone notizie, abbiamo trovato un account attivo con questa email!
Puoi accedere qui.
Hai dimenticato la tua password?
Clicca qui per resettare la tua password.
A verification link has been sent to your email account!
Please click on the link that has been sent to your email account to verify your email and continue the registration process.
We have found that your academic organisation currently subscribes to vLex.
To receive access to vLex:
- Please contact your resource manager to setup an account.
- If you have an email address with the organisation, please use that.
We have found that your organisation currently subscribes to vlex.
To receive access to vLex:
- Use the following link to sign up from your portal.
- Please contact your resource manager to setup an account.
- If you have an email address with the organisation, please use that.
OR
You can signup for an individual account here.
Gli abbonati possono vedere una lista di tutti i casi citati e la legislazione di un documento.
You can sign up for a trial and make the most of our service including these benefits.
Ci sono molte altre ragioni per abbonarsi.
-
Global Coverage
Access over 120 million legal information documents, including the largest collection of common law and civil law content on one intuitive and advanced service.
-
Updated with over 20,000 cases each month
Each month thousands of new cases and legal documents are added to vLex Justis, providing you with up-to-date content and a wider range of information to support your research.
-
AI-powered research
Are you confident your research is complete? Use our AI-powered tool, Vincent, to conduct truly comprehensive research, based on in-document search and analysis.
-
Know where to start your research
The only service to feature exclusive, comprehensive and up-to-date legal information from 130 jurisdictions. This includes the largest collections of common and civil law judgments, exclusive law reports, legislation, regulations, dockets, books, journals and international news.
Buone notizie, abbiamo trovato un account attivo con questa email!
Puoi accedere qui.
Hai dimenticato la tua password?
Clicca qui per resettare la tua password.
A verification link has been sent to your email account!
Please click on the link that has been sent to your email account to verify your email and continue the registration process.
We have found that your academic organisation currently subscribes to vLex.
To receive access to vLex:
- Please contact your resource manager to setup an account.
- If you have an email address with the organisation, please use that.
We have found that your organisation currently subscribes to vlex.
To receive access to vLex:
- Use the following link to sign up from your portal.
- Please contact your resource manager to setup an account.
- If you have an email address with the organisation, please use that.
OR
You can signup for an individual account here.
Gli abbonati possono vedere una lista di tutti i documenti che hanno citato il caso.
You can sign up for a trial and make the most of our service including these benefits.
Ci sono molte altre ragioni per abbonarsi.
-
Global Coverage
Access over 120 million legal information documents, including the largest collection of common law and civil law content on one intuitive and advanced service.
-
Updated with over 20,000 cases each month
Each month thousands of new cases and legal documents are added to vLex Justis, providing you with up-to-date content and a wider range of information to support your research.
-
AI-powered research
Are you confident your research is complete? Use our AI-powered tool, Vincent, to conduct truly comprehensive research, based on in-document search and analysis.
-
Know where to start your research
The only service to feature exclusive, comprehensive and up-to-date legal information from 130 jurisdictions. This includes the largest collections of common and civil law judgments, exclusive law reports, legislation, regulations, dockets, books, journals and international news.
Buone notizie, abbiamo trovato un account attivo con questa email!
Puoi accedere qui.
Hai dimenticato la tua password?
Clicca qui per resettare la tua password.
A verification link has been sent to your email account!
Please click on the link that has been sent to your email account to verify your email and continue the registration process.
We have found that your academic organisation currently subscribes to vLex.
To receive access to vLex:
- Please contact your resource manager to setup an account.
- If you have an email address with the organisation, please use that.
We have found that your organisation currently subscribes to vlex.
To receive access to vLex:
- Use the following link to sign up from your portal.
- Please contact your resource manager to setup an account.
- If you have an email address with the organisation, please use that.
OR
You can signup for an individual account here.
Gli abbonati possono vedere tutte le eventuali correzioni effettuate sul caso.
You can sign up for a trial and make the most of our service including these benefits.
Ci sono molte altre ragioni per abbonarsi.
-
Global Coverage
Access over 120 million legal information documents, including the largest collection of common law and civil law content on one intuitive and advanced service.
-
Updated with over 20,000 cases each month
Each month thousands of new cases and legal documents are added to vLex Justis, providing you with up-to-date content and a wider range of information to support your research.
-
AI-powered research
Are you confident your research is complete? Use our AI-powered tool, Vincent, to conduct truly comprehensive research, based on in-document search and analysis.
-
Know where to start your research
The only service to feature exclusive, comprehensive and up-to-date legal information from 130 jurisdictions. This includes the largest collections of common and civil law judgments, exclusive law reports, legislation, regulations, dockets, books, journals and international news.
Buone notizie, abbiamo trovato un account attivo con questa email!
Puoi accedere qui.
Hai dimenticato la tua password?
Clicca qui per resettare la tua password.
A verification link has been sent to your email account!
Please click on the link that has been sent to your email account to verify your email and continue the registration process.
We have found that your academic organisation currently subscribes to vLex.
To receive access to vLex:
- Please contact your resource manager to setup an account.
- If you have an email address with the organisation, please use that.
We have found that your organisation currently subscribes to vlex.
To receive access to vLex:
- Use the following link to sign up from your portal.
- Please contact your resource manager to setup an account.
- If you have an email address with the organisation, please use that.
OR
You can signup for an individual account here.
Gli abbonati hanno accesso ad una rappresentazione grafica delle relazioni tra il caso corrente e i casi a lui collegati. Un'alternativa alla lista dei casi, la 'Mappa dei Precedenti', rende più facile stabilire quale caso ha maggiore rilevanza nella tua ricerca e permette di capire quali casi meritano un ulteriore approfondimento. La visione d'insieme permette inoltre di capire come il caso è stato ricevuto

Ci sono molte altre ragioni per abbonarsi.
-
Global Coverage
Access over 120 million legal information documents, including the largest collection of common law and civil law content on one intuitive and advanced service.
-
Updated with over 20,000 cases each month
Each month thousands of new cases and legal documents are added to vLex Justis, providing you with up-to-date content and a wider range of information to support your research.
-
AI-powered research
Are you confident your research is complete? Use our AI-powered tool, Vincent, to conduct truly comprehensive research, based on in-document search and analysis.
-
Know where to start your research
The only service to feature exclusive, comprehensive and up-to-date legal information from 130 jurisdictions. This includes the largest collections of common and civil law judgments, exclusive law reports, legislation, regulations, dockets, books, journals and international news.
Buone notizie, abbiamo trovato un account attivo con questa email!
Puoi accedere qui.
Hai dimenticato la tua password?
Clicca qui per resettare la tua password.
A verification link has been sent to your email account!
Please click on the link that has been sent to your email account to verify your email and continue the registration process.
We have found that your academic organisation currently subscribes to vLex.
To receive access to vLex:
- Please contact your resource manager to setup an account.
- If you have an email address with the organisation, please use that.
We have found that your organisation currently subscribes to vlex.
To receive access to vLex:
- Use the following link to sign up from your portal.
- Please contact your resource manager to setup an account.
- If you have an email address with the organisation, please use that.
OR
You can signup for an individual account here.
Gli abbonati possono vedere la lista dei risultati collegati al tuo documento attraverso gli argomenti e le citazioni che Vincent ha trovato.
You can sign up for a trial and make the most of our service including these benefits.
Ci sono molte altre ragioni per abbonarsi.
-
Global Coverage
Access over 120 million legal information documents, including the largest collection of common law and civil law content on one intuitive and advanced service.
-
Updated with over 20,000 cases each month
Each month thousands of new cases and legal documents are added to vLex Justis, providing you with up-to-date content and a wider range of information to support your research.
-
AI-powered research
Are you confident your research is complete? Use our AI-powered tool, Vincent, to conduct truly comprehensive research, based on in-document search and analysis.
-
Know where to start your research
The only service to feature exclusive, comprehensive and up-to-date legal information from 130 jurisdictions. This includes the largest collections of common and civil law judgments, exclusive law reports, legislation, regulations, dockets, books, journals and international news.
Buone notizie, abbiamo trovato un account attivo con questa email!
Puoi accedere qui.
Hai dimenticato la tua password?
Clicca qui per resettare la tua password.
A verification link has been sent to your email account!
Please click on the link that has been sent to your email account to verify your email and continue the registration process.
We have found that your academic organisation currently subscribes to vLex.
To receive access to vLex:
- Please contact your resource manager to setup an account.
- If you have an email address with the organisation, please use that.
We have found that your organisation currently subscribes to vlex.
To receive access to vLex:
- Use the following link to sign up from your portal.
- Please contact your resource manager to setup an account.
- If you have an email address with the organisation, please use that.
OR
You can signup for an individual account here.